Fire
service rating for City of La Habra Heights takes a plunge!
La Habra Heights, CA
(Permission
to reprint in whole or in part is granted)
Contact:
George Edwardz at (888) 867-6620
March 25, 2007
ISO's Chicago Office confirms new pending classification of 5/9 for fire prone
community. The latest report calls for a reclassification of fire suppression
ability for La Habra Heights, which was requested by the City's Fire Chief.
Chief Nielsen initiated a request for ISO to reevaluate the
classification rating, as he stated
at the June 8, 2006 city council meeting, with the intent to show fire
service to be adequate and even improved under his leadership, and
therefore not in need of reform.
So what does the ISO rating mean? ISO, Insurance Services Office, collects
information on municipal fire protection efforts in communities throughout
the United States. ISO analyzes the relevant data using their fire
suppression rating schedule (FSRS). Based on the findings, they
assign a public protection classification from 1 to 10. Class 1
represents exemplary public protection, and class 10 indicates that the
area's fire suppression program doesn't meet ISO's minimum criteria. It is
important to note that ISO only rates a community's ability to respond
to structure fires, not brush fires or medical aid.
On Monday, March 19, the city received a rude awakening upon notification that
the new pending classification by the independent fire rating organization ISO
would be a 5/9, a regression from ISO classification of 3/9. The city's fire service has not been issued
such a low classification in over 20 years! This, despite a
growing budget of over $1 million. The sole rating for just the fire
department alone was a 6, down from a 4. The water department,
which also makes up a significant portion of the classification, continued
to make improvements, but fell to an ISO 3 from an ISO 1 classification achieved
back in 2001. Thus, hurting the ability of the water department to balance
out the fire portion of the rating.
Portions of La Habra Heights fall into a 9 classification due to the lack of
adequate water resources. So in order to improve the greater
community's rating it is sometimes split into two classifications. Such is
the case in La Habra Heights with a pending 5/9 classification.
The homes and properties in the 9 area are basically considered to
be a loss due to the lack of proper water supplies for firefighting. Otherwise, the single classification for the city would most
likely be a 7. Which would force dramatic and costly changes to our
water supply system and fire department to improve on that rating.
Key findings in the report are: Lack of proper receiving and handling of
fire alarms; inadequately equipped first due and reserve fire apparatus; and
training programs in need of improvement. Three engine companies are needed
for the city's size, La Habra Heights only averages 1engine, and 2 are
needed to respond to a building fire. In addition, 2 more fire stations are
needed to improve the rating. Also, according to the report "The
credit for engine companies has been reduced by 50 percent due to the lack
of adequate response to part of the city." In the 2001 ISO Report,
the city had 5 engine companies and a better rating for distribution of fire
companies throughout the community.
The city has 30 days to respond to the letter received March 19, 2007 and 90
days to put in place a plan for corrective measures, otherwise the
information will be published in 1 year and provided to ISO's subscribing
clients "...(insurance companies) to use as they see fit."
Copies of the ISO report are being provided at La Habra Heights City Hall
and the La Habra Heights County Water Department, via the California Public
Records Act of 2004.
Resident firefighters suggest that there are a number of things that the City could implement
immediately to improve the ISO rating. These include: a paid
Automatic Aid agreement with LACOFD, a resident firefighter program,
placement of a water tender in the City and working with Los
Angeles County Fire Department and The County Board of Supervisors to
jointly build or reopen a fire station in the eastern portion of the
community.